Kanu Trial: Fresh Legal Argument Questions Omotosho’s Reliance on Repealed Laws




By Staff Reporter
October 9, 2026

A fresh legal challenge to the conviction of detained Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) leader, Mazi Nnamdi Kanu, has raised questions over the application of the Evidence Act 2011 by Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court in Abuja.

The challenge alleges that the judge selectively applied Section 122 of the Evidence Act, failed to address a request for judicial notice made by Kanu during his trial, and disregarded binding Supreme Court precedent concerning the recognition of laws by Nigerian courts.

At the centre of the dispute is whether the court properly considered Kanu’s arguments regarding the legal provisions underpinning the charges against him before delivering its judgment on November 20, 2025.

The challenge maintains that the alleged errors raise serious questions about the legal foundation of the conviction and warrant further judicial consideration.

How Justice Omotosho Relied on Section 122

The legal argument refers to page 34 of the certified judgment in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CR/383/2015, Federal Republic of Nigeria v. Mazi Nnamdi Kanu.

According to the challenge, Justice Omotosho acknowledged that courts are required to take judicial notice of the laws of Nigeria, as well as gazetted orders and rulings of courts of coordinate jurisdiction, under Section 122 of the Evidence Act 2011.

The judge reportedly relied on the provision to take judicial notice of an order made by Justice Kafarati in a separate case concerning the proscription of IPOB.

However, the challenge argues that the same statutory provision was not applied when Kanu sought judicial notice of laws he believed were relevant to the validity of the charges against him.

It contends that this difference in treatment raises questions about the consistency with which the court applied the law.

Why the Word ‘Shall’ Matters

The challenge places significant emphasis on Section 122(2)(a) of the Evidence Act 2011, which provides for judicial notice of laws and enactments, including subsidiary legislation having the force of law in Nigeria.

Its central argument concerns the use of the word shall, which it interprets as imposing a mandatory duty on courts rather than granting them discretion.

The argument also cites the Supreme Court decision in INEC v. Etene, which it says supports the principle that statutory provisions expressed in mandatory language must be complied with.

On that basis, the challenge maintains that a court cannot treat the statutory obligation as optional simply because a particular law is raised by the defence rather than the prosecution.

Whether the provision required the court to take judicial notice of the specific matters raised by Kanu remains a legal question that must be assessed against the relevant statutory text, the trial record and applicable judicial decisions.

Supreme Court Precedent Also Under Scrutiny

Another key issue raised by the challenge is the Supreme Court decision in Appeal No. SC/CR/1361/2022, delivered on December 15, 2023.

The argument refers to the lead judgment of Justice Lawal Garba, JSC, and maintains that the Supreme Court reaffirmed the obligation of Nigerian courts to take judicial notice of applicable statutory enactments, including repealed legislation where relevant.

According to the challenge, the Federal High Court was bound to follow applicable legal principles established by the Supreme Court under the doctrine of stare decisis.

The doctrine requires lower courts to follow binding decisions of higher courts on applicable legal questions.

The challenge consequently alleges that the trial court failed to properly apply the relevant principles when considering Kanu’s arguments concerning the laws under which he was being prosecuted.

What Kanu Allegedly Asked the Court to Consider

The challenge also refers to proceedings conducted on November 4 and 5, 2025, when Kanu appeared in court without legal representation.

It cites page 973 of the trial record, claiming that Kanu asked the court to take judicial notice of what he described as the repeal of the Terrorism Prevention (Amendment) Act 2013 and the non-existence of the Criminal Code Act C-45.

Kanu reportedly argued that criminal proceedings could not lawfully continue under legislation that was no longer in force and that the prosecution needed to establish the applicable legal framework.

The challenge maintains that his request raised a substantive legal question that required determination before the trial proceeded.

It further alleges that the court continued with the proceedings without adequately resolving the issue.

However, the precise legal effect of the alleged repeal, the applicability of any replacement legislation and the status of the charges would need to be established by examining the relevant enactments and the complete court record.

Dispute Over ‘Assuming Without Conceding’

The challenge also questions the use of the phrase assuming without conceding in Justice Omotosho’s final judgment.

It argues that an assumption made in a judgment cannot substitute for a judicial determination of a statutory issue previously raised by a defendant.

According to the argument, judicial notice involves a court recognising a matter that the law requires or permits it to accept without formal proof, whereas an assumption is a hypothetical position adopted for the purpose of reasoning.

The challenge therefore contends that the two concepts cannot automatically be treated as interchangeable.

It describes the judgment as potentially per incuriam—a legal term used to describe a decision reached in ignorance of a relevant statutory provision or binding authority.

Whether that description applies to the judgment would depend on the precise issues decided, the applicable law and the authorities considered by the court.

Allegation of Unequal Treatment

A further allegation concerns what the challenge describes as inconsistent treatment of the prosecution and defence.

It contrasts the court’s reliance on Section 122 to recognise Justice Kafarati’s proscription order with its alleged failure to apply the same provision when Kanu raised questions about the laws underpinning his charges.

The argument maintains that the Evidence Act should be applied consistently, regardless of which party invokes it.

It argues that any failure to determine the defence’s request could have affected the fairness and legal validity of the proceedings.

These claims represent the position advanced by the legal challenge and should be distinguished from findings formally made by an appellate court.

What the Legal Challenge Seeks to Establish

The challenge identifies several issues it believes require judicial scrutiny:

  • Whether Justice Omotosho properly applied Section 122 of the Evidence Act 2011.
  • Whether Kanu’s request for judicial notice was adequately considered and determined.
  • Whether the relevant Supreme Court decisions were binding on the trial court in the circumstances.
  • Whether the court correctly addressed the legal status of the enactments relevant to the charges.
  • Whether any identified errors of law could affect the validity of the conviction.

The central contention is that a conviction must rest on applicable law and proceedings conducted in accordance with the requirements of the legal system.

The challenge argues that if the trial court failed to address a mandatory statutory requirement or overlooked binding judicial authority, the alleged error could become a significant issue in the appeal.

Nevertheless, the allegations do not, by themselves, establish that the conviction is invalid. That question ultimately depends on the applicable law, the complete record and the determination of the competent appellate court.

Conclusion

The latest challenge has placed the interpretation of Section 122 of the Evidence Act 2011, the doctrine of judicial notice and the application of Supreme Court precedent at the centre of the legal debate surrounding Nnamdi Kanu’s conviction.

Its proponents argue that the court must explain how the statutory provision was applied to the prosecution’s case and why, according to their account, the defence’s request was not given equivalent consideration.

The matter also raises broader questions about the importance of addressing substantive legal objections, particularly when a defendant appears without legal representation.

As the legal dispute continues, the decisive issue will be whether the alleged errors can be demonstrated from the judgment, the trial record and the governing law.

The challenge ends with a demand for legal clarity:

“An assumption is not judicial notice. A dead law cannot sustain a conviction. Show us the law.”

Suggested SEO headline: Nnamdi Kanu’s Conviction: Fresh Challenge Questions Justice Omotosho’s Application of Evidence Act

Suggested meta description: A fresh legal challenge to Nnamdi Kanu’s conviction questions Justice Omotosho’s application of Section 122 of the Evidence Act and the treatment of Supreme Court precedent.

Editorial note: Before publishing, verify the cited judgment, the exact wording of Section 122, the Supreme Court decision and the relevant trial-record pages. This will help ensure the report accurately distinguishes the legal challenge’s allegations from established judicial findings.


0/Post a Comment/Comments