A Rogue Conviction: How Omotosho Overruled the National Assembly and Buried His Own Bench in Contempt of Court





Nigerian lawyer Onyedikachi Ifedi has raised fresh legal questions over the conviction and sentencing of Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) leader, Mazi Nnamdi Kanu, alleging that Justice James Omotosho failed to comply with mandatory transitional provisions of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act 2022.

In the seventh instalment of his 150-part legal commentary on the judgment delivered on November 20, 2025, Ifedi argued that the trial judge committed what he described as a fundamental jurisdictional error by continuing Kanu’s trial under the earlier terrorism legislation instead of applying the 2022 Act.

The lawyer specifically questioned the court’s decision to reject an application by Kanu seeking the transfer of the charges from the Terrorism Prevention (Amendment) Act 2013 to the 2022 legislation.

Lawyer Cites Sections 97 and 98 of the 2022 Act

According to Ifedi, Sections 97 and 98(2) of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act 2022 contain mandatory transitional provisions which, in his interpretation, required pending proceedings to be brought within the framework of the new legislation.

He maintained that the trial court’s refusal to grant the defence application raised serious legal and constitutional concerns, particularly under Section 36(12) of the 1999 Constitution.

The constitutional provision prohibits the conviction of a person for a criminal offence unless the offence is defined and its penalty prescribed in a written law.

Ifedi argued that the court’s decision to continue with the earlier legislation, despite the enactment of the 2022 Act, raised questions about the legal foundation upon which the conviction was delivered.

Ifedi References Supreme Court Decision

The lawyer also relied on a Supreme Court decision which, according to his interpretation, established that a court must possess jurisdiction under a valid and subsisting law before it can lawfully try a defendant.

He argued that Justice Omotosho’s rejection of the defence application and subsequent judgment under the earlier legislation were inconsistent with the legal principles he cited.

Ifedi further questioned the interpretation of Section 98(3) of the 2022 Act, which contains savings provisions relating to matters arising under the previous legislation.

According to him, the savings provision should not be interpreted as allowing pending criminal proceedings to continue indefinitely under repealed legislation.

He maintained that while Section 98(3) preserved certain existing proceedings, Sections 97 and 98(2) provided the transitional framework for dealing with pending cases under the new legal regime.

Questions Raised Over Jurisdiction and Fair Trial

Ifedi also invoked the Supreme Court’s decision in Madukolu v. Nkemdilim, a landmark case on the conditions a court must satisfy before exercising jurisdiction.

He argued that failure to comply with mandatory statutory requirements could affect the validity of judicial proceedings and provide grounds for challenging a conviction on appeal.

The lawyer therefore maintained that the alleged failure to apply the relevant provisions of the 2022 Act could have significant implications for the legal sustainability of the judgment against Kanu.

Lawyer Questions Rejection of Defence Application

In his commentary, Ifedi questioned why the trial court rejected the defence’s request for the application of the 2022 legislation, arguing that the issue required detailed judicial consideration.

He also suggested that the newer legislation contained procedural and evidentiary safeguards that could have affected the prosecution’s case.

However, his position on how the application of the 2022 Act might have affected the outcome of the trial remains a legal argument and has not been established by an appellate determination.

Appeal Could Examine Application of the 2022 Act

The lawyer maintained that the alleged jurisdictional errors should be examined by the appellate court, arguing that the complete court record would be essential in determining whether the trial judge complied with the applicable statutory and constitutional requirements.

He called for a detailed examination of Sections 97 and 98 of the 2022 Act, the Supreme Court authorities cited in his commentary and the proceedings that led to Kanu’s conviction.

The central issue raised in the seventh instalment is whether Section 98(3) permitted the continuation of Kanu’s trial under the earlier legislation or whether the transitional provisions required the proceedings to be handled under the 2022 Act.

According to Ifedi, resolving that question is important to determining the legality of the proceedings and the validity of the resulting judgment.

His latest submission adds another dimension to the ongoing legal debate surrounding Kanu’s conviction, particularly the interpretation of transitional provisions, the jurisdiction of criminal courts and the constitutional requirements governing criminal trials.


0/Post a Comment/Comments