THE DISBARRED LAWYER'S EVASION: HOW EMEKA UGWUONYE AND ECULAW DODGED THE CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS IN NNAMDI KANU'S CONVICTION



Onyedikachi Ifedi, Esq., of the Global Legal Consortium, has launched a strong criticism of Nigerian legal commentator Emeka Ugwuonye and his Eculaw Group, accusing them of avoiding the substantive legal issues surrounding the conviction of detained IPOB leader, Mazi Nnamdi Kanu.

In a strongly worded response titled “The Toxic Desperation of a Disbarred Fraudster,” Ifedi questioned Ugwuonye’s recent commentary on Kanu’s case, arguing that it failed to address what he described as fundamental constitutional, statutory and procedural defects contained in the 115-page appellant brief.

Ifedi maintained that rather than examining the legal arguments presented by Kanu’s defence, Ugwuonye focused on broader discussions about leadership, political representation and the Biafra movement.

The lawyer described this approach as a diversion from the central legal questions surrounding the conviction and challenged Ugwuonye and Eculaw to respond to five specific issues.

Ifedi Raises Five Questions for Ugwuonye and Eculaw

According to Ifedi, Ugwuonye’s commentary failed to address several questions that he considers essential to understanding the legal and political circumstances surrounding Kanu’s trial.

1. Who Is Responsible for the Insecurity in the South-East?

The first question concerns the origins of insecurity in the South-East.

Ifedi questioned whether IPOB, Kanu and the civilian population should be blamed for the region’s security challenges or whether the Nigerian government’s military operations and security crackdowns contributed to the situation.

He accused Ugwuonye of focusing on the activities of separatist groups while overlooking allegations of excessive force and other human rights violations during security operations in the region.

Ifedi argued that any meaningful discussion of insecurity in Igboland must also examine the actions of state security agencies and the circumstances surrounding their operations.

2. What Terrorist Activity Was Attributed to IPOB Before Its Proscription?

The second question focuses on the legal foundation of IPOB’s proscription in 2018.

Ifedi challenged Ugwuonye to identify specific terrorist activities that were established against IPOB before the organisation was proscribed by the Federal High Court.

He questioned the evidentiary basis of the proscription order granted by Justice Abdul Kafarati and maintained that the application suffered from a fundamental defect involving the alleged absence of presidential approval.

According to Ifedi, the memorandum relied upon in the proscription proceedings bore the signature of Abba Kyari, the late Chief of Staff to former President Muhammadu Buhari, rather than that of the President.

He argued that Section 2(1)(c) of the Terrorism (Prevention) Act 2011, as amended in 2013, required presidential approval and that an administrative aide could not automatically exercise a statutory responsibility assigned to the President.

The MultiChoice Judgment and the Alleged Judicial Double Standard

To reinforce his argument, Ifedi referred to Justice James Omotosho’s May 8, 2025, judgment in MultiChoice Nigeria Ltd v. Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC).

He cited the judge’s reported pronouncement:

“The power to fix prices is exclusively that of the President. Any decision taken without such delegation is a nullity.”

Ifedi argued that Justice Omotosho applied strict requirements of presidential authorisation in the MultiChoice dispute but failed to apply what he considers the same legal standard when considering the IPOB proscription order in FRN v. Nnamdi Kanu.

He maintained that the court accepted a memorandum bearing Abba Kyari’s signature as sufficient authority for the proscription process, despite his contention that the relevant legislation required presidential approval.

The lawyer described this as an inconsistency in the judge’s reasoning and questioned why Ugwuonye and Eculaw had not addressed the issue in their commentary.

For Ifedi, the question of whether the proscription application satisfied the statutory requirements remains central to the legal arguments challenging the proceedings against Kanu.

3. Is Biafra About Nnamdi Kanu Alone?

The third question addresses Ugwuonye’s reported argument that Biafra should not be treated as the personal property of Nnamdi Kanu.

Ifedi rejected what he described as an attempt to frame the Biafra movement as an individual project belonging exclusively to Kanu.

He argued that support for self-determination exists independently of any single individual and that the movement’s political aspirations should not be confused with the legal issues surrounding Kanu’s prosecution.

According to him, the central concern is not whether Kanu owns the Biafra movement but whether the proceedings against him complied with the Nigerian Constitution and applicable laws.

He identified the alleged use of repealed legislation, questions surrounding the proscription order and the defence’s right to a fair hearing as issues requiring serious legal consideration.

4. Is Kanu’s Conviction Supported by Law, Procedure and Evidence?

Ifedi described this as the most important question Ugwuonye and Eculaw allegedly avoided.

He argued that acknowledging the November 20, 2025, conviction without examining the legal grounds upon which it was based does not adequately address the issues raised by Kanu’s defence.

The lawyer identified several arguments contained in the 115-page appellant brief.

Use of repealed legislation: Ifedi questioned how the conviction could stand under Section 36(12) of the 1999 Constitution if the trial court relied on provisions of the Terrorism (Prevention) (Amendment) Act 2013 and the Criminal Code or other applicable legislation he maintains had been repealed before the trial recommenced.

He referenced the Supreme Court decision in State v. Egigia, arguing that the applicable law at the relevant time must be carefully considered when determining criminal liability.

Alleged absence of a specifically pleaded terrorist act: The lawyer also questioned whether the prosecution properly identified and established specific terrorist acts in the charge and through the evidence presented at trial.

He argued that speeches allegedly made on Radio Biafra should not automatically be treated as proof of terrorism without examining the precise offences charged and the evidence required to establish them.

Refusal to allow a final written address: Ifedi further challenged the trial court’s alleged refusal to allow the defence to file or present a final written address.

He maintained that the decision violated Kanu’s right to fair hearing and relied on Obiakor v. State and Okafor v. State in support of his argument that the denial of an opportunity to present a final address could undermine the validity of criminal proceedings.

Federal Government’s cross-appeal: The lawyer also referred to what he described as an admission by the Federal Government in Ground One of its cross-appeal that the trial court lacked jurisdiction when it imposed life imprisonment.

He argued that the alleged admission raises a significant jurisdictional question that deserves consideration by the appellate court.

Ifedi maintained that these issues cannot be dismissed through political commentary and challenged Ugwuonye to address the actual legal arguments presented in the appeal.

5. Why Were the Legal Issues Not Addressed?

The fifth question concerns what Ifedi considers Ugwuonye’s failure to engage with the specific legal arguments in Kanu’s appellant brief.

He accused the Eculaw Group of concentrating on political and sociological discussions rather than responding to the constitutional and procedural questions raised by the defence.

Ifedi suggested that the approach was intended to divert public attention from what he described as serious defects in Justice Omotosho’s judgment.

He maintained that any meaningful legal assessment of the conviction must address the relevant statutes, court decisions, trial proceedings and arguments presented by both sides.

Ifedi Questions Ugwuonye’s Professional Status

Beyond the substantive legal issues, Ifedi also challenged Ugwuonye’s professional credibility by referring to a disciplinary decision involving his status as a Nigerian legal practitioner.

He claimed that Ugwuonye’s name was struck off the Roll of Legal Practitioners following disciplinary proceedings over alleged infamous conduct.

To support his position, Ifedi referenced a notification reportedly issued by the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court on April 24, 2018.

The document, which he identified as reference number 197/SCN/LIT/100118, reportedly concerned disciplinary case number BB/LPDC/217/16, involving the Nigerian Bar Association and Ephraim Emeka Ugwuonye.

According to the quotation reproduced by Ifedi, the notification stated:

“UGWUONYE EPHRAIM CHUKWUEMEKA is not entitled to practice as a Barrister and Solicitor of the Supreme Court of Nigeria… any letter issued to you before now with regards to your enrolment status is null and void.”

Ifedi relied on the document to question Ugwuonye’s authority to present himself as a legal practitioner in Nigeria and to offer commentary on complex constitutional litigation.

He also criticised the activities of Eculaw Group, describing its legal commentary as unreliable.

However, the status of Ugwuonye’s enrolment and the precise scope of any disciplinary decision are matters that require confirmation from the relevant official records.

Conclusion: Ifedi Says Kanu’s Appeal Must Be Decided on Legal Merits

In his concluding remarks, Ifedi maintained that public commentary cannot resolve the legal questions surrounding Kanu’s conviction.

He argued that the 115-page appellant brief raises issues concerning the application of repealed legislation, the validity of the IPOB proscription order, the denial of a final written address, the prosecution’s evidence and the trial court’s jurisdiction.

According to him, these arguments remain unanswered by Ugwuonye and Eculaw.

Ifedi also accused Ugwuonye of using personal attacks and political commentary to avoid engaging with the legal record.

He insisted that the fate of Kanu’s conviction should ultimately be determined by the appellate court on the basis of the Constitution, applicable legislation, judicial precedents and evidence presented during the proceedings.

The lawyer concluded that a conviction allegedly affected by fundamental jurisdictional and procedural defects cannot be defended merely through public commentary or political arguments.

Onyedikachi Ifedi, Esq.
For: Global Legal Consortium


0/Post a Comment/Comments